Courses
List

These Courses

Jesus & Origins
Judaism
NT Communities
Wisdom in OT
Images of God
Johannine
Hellenist Era
Matt's Gospel
Paul and the EC
Bible & Ecology
Courses on CD


Old_Test.
List
Genesis
Exodus
Leviticus
Numbers
Deuteronomy

Joshua
Judges
Ruth
1Samuel
2Samuel
1Kings
2Kings
1Chronicles
2Chronicles
Ezra
Nehemiah
Esther

Psalms
Proverbs
Job
Ecclesiastes
Song
Isaiah
Jeremiah
Baruch
Ezekiel
Daniel
Hosea
Joel
Amos
Obadiah
Jonah
Micah
Nahum
Habbakuk
Zephaniah
Haggai
Zechariah
Malachi

Tobit
Judith
1Maccabees
2Maccabees
Sirach
Baruch
Wisdom
New_Test.
List
Matthew
Mark
Luke
John
Acts
Romans
1Corinthians
2Corinthians
Galatians
Ephesians
Colossians
1Thessalonians
2Thessalonians
Philemon
1Timothy
2Timothy
Titus
Hebrews
James
1 Peter
2Peter
1-3John
Jude
Revelation
Josephus
List
Who was Josephus?
Maps, Graphics
Highlights
Translation

THE JEWISH WAR
War, Volume 1
War, Volume 2
War, Volume 3
War, Volume 4
War, Volume 5
War, Volume 6
War, Volume 7

THE ANTIQUITIES
Ant. Jud., Bk 1
Ant. Jud., Bk 2
Ant. Jud., Bk 3
Ant. Jud., Bk 4
Ant. Jud., Bk 5
Ant. Jud., Bk 6
Ant. Jud., Bk 7
Ant. Jud., Bk 8
Ant. Jud., Bk 9
Ant. Jud., Bk 10
Ant. Jud., Bk 11
Ant. Jud., Bk 12
Ant. Jud., Bk 13
Ant. Jud., Bk 14
Ant. Jud., Bk 15
Ant. Jud., Bk 16
Ant. Jud., Bk 17
Ant. Jud., Bk 18
Ant. Jud., Bk 19
Ant. Jud., Bk 20

OTHER WRITINGS
Apion, Bk 1
Apion, Bk 2
Autobiog.


Apocrypha
List
Introduction

Gospel of--
-- Nicodemus
-- Peter
-- Ps-Matthew
-- James (Protevangelium)
-- Thomas (Infancy)
-- Joseph of Arimathea
-- Joseph the Carpenter
Pilate's Letter
Pilate's End

Apocalypse of --
-- Ezra
-- Moses
-- Paul
-- Pseudo-John
-- Moses
-- Enoch

Various
Clementine Homilies
Clementine Letters
Clementine Recognitions
Dormition of Mary
Book of Jubilees
Life of Adam and Eve
Odes of Solomon
Pistis Sophia
Secrets of Enoch
Tests_12_Patriarchs
Veronica's Veil
Vision of Paul
Vision of Shadrach

Acts of
Andrew
Andrew & Matthias
Andrew & Peter
Barnabas
Bartholomew
John
Matthew
Paul & Perpetua
Paul & Thecla
Peter & Paul
Andrew and Peter
Barnabas
Philip & Bartholomew
Pilate
Thaddaeus
Thomas in India
Readings
List

Sundays of
Advent
Xmastide
Lent-A
Lent-B
Lent-C
Easter-A
Easter-B
Easter-C

Funerals
Weddings

Ord-Time Year-A
Suns 1-11
Suns 12-22
Suns 23-34

Ord-Time Year-B
Suns 1-11
Suns 12-22
Suns 23-34

Ord-Time Year-C
Suns 1-11
Suns 12-22
Suns 23-34

Weekdays of
Advent
Lent
Eastertide
Ord-Wks 1-11
Ord-Wks 12-22
Ord-Wks 23-34

Patristic
List


Clement of Rome

Ignatius of Antioch

Polycarp of Smyrna<

Barnabas,(Epistle of)

Papias of Hierapolis

Justin, Martyr

The Didachë

Irenaeus of Lyons

Hermas (Pastor of)

Tatian of Syria

Theophilus of Antioch

Diognetus (letter)

Athenagoras of Alex.

Clement of Alexandria

Tertullian of Carthage

Origen of Alexandria

Cyberbooks
(books on CD)

Study-Software
(to enhance your computer)

Bible Study
(The Bible text and
some major commentaries)

Inspirations
(Dozens of seminal works
on Theology & Spirituality)

Classic Texts
(Theology, Philosophy,
+ Literature and Classics)


Order a CD

First Thessalonians

 

 

First Thessalonians,
Paul's earliest surviving letter

Thessalonica: the city

Paul's "founding visit" to Thessalonica

Date and Place of Writing 1 Thessalonians

Purpose of 1 Thess

The tone of Epistle

Paul's Opponents, in Thessalonica

Exegetical notes

A) Address and Greeting 1:1-2

B) Thanksgiving 1:3-l0

C)  Body of the Letter (1 Th 2:1 - 3:13): Kindly Reminiscence

D) Exhortations  (4:1-5:24)

The prevailing mood and spirit

 

 

 

Thessalonica: the city

          The ancient Macedonian city of Thessalonica occupied (and still occupies) the plain beneath Mount Khortiatis, overlooking the Thermaic Gulf in the Aegean Sea. The city was founded in 315 bC, by Cassander, a general under Alexander the Great, and is named after Thessalo­nike, Alexander's half‑sister.          Its location favoured the city's development and prosperity. It is the natural commercial and cultural center for  Macedonia, as the most important port in the northern Aegean.  Already a regional market center, the city was further enriched by its posi­tion on the Via Egnatia, Rome's trans‑Macedonia highway.

 

          Thessalonica came under Roman control in 168 bC  In 146 it became capital of the newly‑formed province of Macedonia. A century later, in the battle of Philippi (42 bC), the city sided with Mark Antony and Octavian ‑ the future Augus­tus ‑ against the republican forces of Cassius and Brutus.  The victors proclaimed Thessalonica a free city and the seat of a proconsul.

          When Augustus reorganized the Roman provinces (27 bC), juris­diction over Macedonia was granted to the sen­ate.  When Paul visited the city, (probably in a:D. 50) it was the capital of a secure and peaceful province, the sister city of Corinth, which was capital of Achaia, its neighboring province to the south. Paul, the urban missionary, concentrated his efforts on influential centres, intending that his message would be spread outward from the cities, by the efforts of his Christian colleagues.

 

          The Thessalonians were of mixed race and religion.  In addition to the old Macedonian stock of the area, Roman colonization had brought in many Italians. Hope of finding prosperity also attracted immigrants from Syria, Judea and north Africa.  This racial mix in Thessalonica entailed a wide diversity of religious cults. Inscrip­tions found on the ruins of the old city show that at least 20 different deities were honored there, including the Roman pantheon and a host of oriental deities. Paul accurately remarked that his converts had to "abandon the worship of false gods" (1:9).

         

Paul's "founding visit" to Thessalonica

          According to Acts (17:1‑10 ) Paul first goes to the local synagogue and argues with the Jews, employing the Scriptures to press his arguments. He has only moderate success there, for only some of them believed and joined the new faith; but there was also a number of God‑fearing Gentiles, friends of the synagogue, who were convinced by him, including some influential women (17:4). This success with the Gentiles angered some of the Jews, who roused the crowds against Paul and Silas, and brought them before the courts. The Roman  authorities did not take the charges seriously, and dismissed them.

 

          Does this report in Acts accurately depict the founding of the church in Thessalonica? Several discordances between this account and details in the letter itself (1 Th), lead to suspicion that Luke was writing to some sort of "formula" rather than recording remembered fact. The discordances fall under these headings:

 

a) the length of Paul's stay:  Acts 17:2 has Paul preaching on just three succes­sive Sabbaths, after which there is the Jewish outcry and his quick departure from the city. The letter seems to imply a rather longer stay, long enough for the Thessalonians to be impressed and taught by his personal example (1:6). It was long enough also for some organized leadership to be established in the com­munity (5:12 "those who preside over you in the Lord").

           At least once during this time in Thessalonika, he received material help from Philippi (Ph 4:16). But it would take several days at least for news of his financial need to reach the Philippians, and as long again for them to respond with their gift.  For these reasons, Murphy O'Connor holds that Paul's founding visit must have lasted about a year (Paul, 102). He may well be right.

 

b) The audience: Did Paul mainly address Jews or Gentiles in Thessalonica? Ac 17:1-10 implies that most of Paul's converts came from the synagogue and its friends. But when he writes back to them, the community consists of Gentile converts, who "turned away from idols to serve the living God" (1 Th l:9). The letter also lacks the layer of OT quotations that will later fea­ture in his letters to communities such as Corinth and Rome, that held a high proportion of Jewish‑Christians. 

          Some critics even wish to dispute (based on the agreed division of ministries reported in Ga 2:7) whether in his missionary travels Paul ever preached to the Jews after the Jerusalem meeting; but this is to over-interpret Paul's schematic division of the mission-field into "the circumcised" and "the uncircumcised", and it would minimise the import of his statement about him becoming "as a Jew, in order to win Jews" (1 Co 9:20).

 

c) The Message: What themes did Paul speak about? Acts' description of his preaching (Christ suffering and rising from the dead; Ac 17:2-3) does not really reflect the themes that Paul himself says he spoke about: conversion from paganism, and expecting the coming of Jesus in Parousia (1 Th 1:10).

 

          Luke's presentation of the visit seems influenced by his literary agenda. We must agree with Haenchen (Acts p:510) that in the Lucan version, Paul's visits to the various towns take a stereotyped form: "the founding of the community and then the persecution which forces the Apostle away to his next goal".  Luke may have had only a minimal report of that visit, as his source, and fleshed it out from his imagination.

 

Date and Place of Writing 1 Thessalonians

          The tone suggests the letter was written soon after Paul's visit to that city; Corinth is the most likely place of writing.  According to Acts 18:12, the apostle's 18-month visit to Corinth reaches into the proconsulship of Gallio, which can be dated 52-53 A:D. *Opponents may have used the arrival of the new proconsul as the occasion for bringing Paul to trial.

                   Paul would have been working in Corinth for 18 months before his arrest, which gives us a date of early 51 for his arrival in the city, followed by the writing of 1 Thess within the few follow­ing months. (See Fitzmyer, NJBC Paul p:1335). For the view that 1 Thess is a compilation of what were originally two letters, see Murphy-O:Connor, Paul, a Critical Life, 105. In this schema, 2:13 - 4:2 is understood as a second letter, written to strengthen the community in time of persecution, and later inserted (by some anonymous copyist) into the middle of the text of letter A.

 

Purpose of 1 Thess

A. Congratulations: Paul worried about the young church ever since he had been compelled to leave it in haste, and had not been able to return to visit it (2:17ff). There­fore he sent Timothy to check on the survival of that little church, and encourage them to bear up under the pressure of persecu­tion.  After a period of anxious waiting, Paul is relieved to hear good news of the Thessalonian Church brought back by young Timothy. He thanks God for their perseverance, their mutual love and their faith.   He is especially pleased that they have:

          1. stood firm in persecution (2:14)

          2. given example to others by their love (1:3, 4:9-12)

          3. remembered Paul himself, with affection (3:6).

 

B. Problem solving: Paul also must address himself to some questions raised by the Thessalonians during Timothy's visit. Moreover, drawing on his pastoral experience, he discusses some problems and issues which he knows would come up in a community like that of Thessalonica.  His instructions fall into three main categories:

          -faith in the return of Jesus

          -exercise of mutual love within the community

          -need for personal moral integrity or holiness in order to share in the glory of Jesus at his return (3:9-13).

 

The tone of Epistle

This first letter of Paul is very pastoral and friendly, encouraging them both with praise and by reminding them of the high ideals to which as Christians they have been called. Clearly he feels a close relationship with them.  At the same time the questions raised show that he did not have the time to finish off the basic doctrinal and moral instructions that these former pagans needed to adopt a total christian lifestyle.

          We find in 1 Thess none of the sharp rebukes that will later be part of the Corinthian and Galatian letters. The Thessalonians have not yet departed in any serious way from the Christian way, though as one always in search of excellence, Paul may suggest that something is still lacking in their faith (3:10). But they are on the right path; they only need additional encouragement and direction (3:12, 4:1, 10), given in the tone of a father to his children (2:11-12), aware of the problems they face.  Here, at the dawn of church history, we glimpse the fervor with which they faced those early combats, and the enthusiasm of their first progress.

 

Paul's Opponents, in Thessalonica

          The tone of 1 Th 2:1-12 certainly sounds like some kind of self-defence, or  apologia.  Paul appeals to the Thessalonians' memory of him during his stay among them:

a. He maintained himself so that no financial burden fell on the local Christian community.  b. He had never been insincere or used flattery, so as to win them over to himself.  c. He made no effort to win a reputation among them.  d. He always treated them affectionately, as a nurse or as a father toward children.

 

          If 2:1-12 was a self defence, to whom was it directed? What kind of critics has Paul in mind? It is unlikely he was confronting a determined group of opponents like the ones he would later in Galatia. It is probably better not to look for one group to blame for all the difficulties. There were in Thessalonica various ideas from the Hellenistic atmosphere which were foreign to christianity's ethos and which Paul had to reject; but "we need not suppose that one single group consciously held together all these ideas and advocated them. The ideas have comes from the prevailing culture and not from a definite set of people:" (E. Best, 1 Thessalonians 22).

         

          Paul's Jewish critics probably continued their campaign against him, even after his hurried departure from the city. How could they better undermine his work than by making accusations against his honesty and sincerity? There were at the time many wandering preachers, teachers and magicians who made their living by teaching or lecturing; and some of these seemed more intent on the money they received and gaining a feeling of self-importance, than on the truth of what they taught. If Paul's critics could classify him among these then his influence would quickly wane. 

                            ********************************

                                     

Exegetical notes

 

A) Address and Greeting 1:1-2

Ekklesia (assembly; church)  This was an important term in Paul's vocabulary.  In the Greek-speaking world it was the term used for the official assembly of the citizens of a city, who had the right and duty to gather for discussion and cast their votes concerning matters of importance for the whole city.

         

          By the time that the Christians adopted it, it also had a long history of religious usage.  It had been used by the Greek translator of the OT to render the Hebrew Qahal, the assembly of the people of God.  The Hebrew word is etymologically connected to the Hebrew qol, "voice". Ekklesia was an apt Greek translation for qahal, since ekklesia comes from the verb kaleo, "to call".  Both terms suggested an action of God, "gathering, calling together, summoning to meet:"  Both the Hebrew and its Greek rendering imply the divine initiative and the active response of those who have been addressed.

 

          The term is variously used by Paul to refer to the world-wide Christian community (1 Co 10:34, 12:28), the Christian community in a certain town (Rm 16:1, 1 Cor 1:2), and even the community meeting in a certain house (Rm 16:5, 1 Co 16:19).  Ernest Best remarks that the usage of one term for all these levels of community indicates that "the whole is not regarded merely as the sum total of its components, but rather that the whole appears as smaller units in particular places, the whole being the basic conception" (61).

 

          Paul addresses the community. His apostolic activity was directed not just to the conversion of indivi­duals but to the founding of churches, groups of believers. The quality of Christian existence, for him, was more than just the purely private adherence of the individual to Jesus Christ.

 

"in God the Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ": Paul links together God the Father and the Lord Jesus without distinguishing their functions in mankind's salvation. The preposition in is here to be understood in an instrumental, causative sense.  The assembly is IN God, because it comes from God's initiative and authority.

 

"Father"- The OT sometimes uses "Father" of God (e:g. Dt 32:6, 2 Sam 7:14, Is 63:16), but not with the simplicity or frequency of the NT,  which derives from the practice of Jesus himself (see Joachim Jeremias, The Prayers of Jesus, London, 1967. 11-65).

 

Grace to you, and peace: In a Greek letter the normal opening would simply have been a form of chairein, "greetings".  Paul has transformed a customary greeting into one with theological meaning. He adds to it the normal Jewish Shalom of greeting, "peace".  Fitzmyer (JBC 47:8) notes how this opening formula "uses the two notions of charis (covenant favor) and eirene (peace) that are rooted in the old priestly blessing of Nm 6:24-26.  Again charis has the Pauline connotation of the merciful bounty of God manifested in Christ Jesus (cf. Rm 5:1-11). The two words are Paul's summation of the blessings of the Christian era.  Its solemnity suggests that it may even be a liturgical formula that has been adapted to epistolary introduction.  These are the spiritual gifts that Paul normal­ly sends to his readers.

 

B) Thanksgiving  1:3-l0

          This thanksgiving is longer than any other in the Pauline letters. In it, Paul compliments the people and hints at the topics to be dealt with in the letter.  The whole thanksgiving is one rambling, untidily constructed sentence, difficult to punctuate but easy to understand.

 

v2 about all of you He keeps both the individuals and their community in mind, and so expresses concern for and interest in all of them.

 

v.3 the "triad" of faith, love and hope  also appears in 1 Co 13:13, Rm 5:1-5, Gal 5:5f, 1 Thess 5:8. See also Col 1:4f, Eph 4:2-5, Heb 6:10-12, 10:22-24, 1 Pt 1:3-8, Barnabas 1:4, 9:8. Probably this triad is not original to St. Paul, but was a common heritage, a sort of compendium of the Christian virtues, in current use in the early apostolic church. 

 

          Each member of the triad is quali­fied with an action-word.  Work of faith is the person's total response to the goodness of God seen in the death and resurrection of Christ through which we are redeemed. Such a total response includes obedience to God and must therefore result in activity (achievement) on the part of the human person.

 

kopos tes agapes ("labor of love")  underlines the demanding, fatigu­ing nature of what true love requires.  Paul used agape in pre­ference to other Greek words for "love" because previously it had not been greatly used, and was not overloaded with specific connotations.  Therefore, Christians were free to pour into the term their own specific meaning.  This term is primarily used to describe Christ's love for us; secon­darily for the love that human beings ought to show toward one another; and thirdly (rarely) as in Rm 8:28, for the love that we direct towards God.

 

hypomone (endurance) was vital for the survival of the faith in a hostile environment. It means steadfast perseverance in face of trials and afflictions. A good parallel is in Rm 12:12 ("Rejoice in your hope, be patient in tribulation, be constant in prayer"), and Lk 21:19 ("by your endurance, you wil gain your lives").

 

elpis, (hope) for Paul is not the off chance that things just might work out, but the confident expectation of salvation that results from what God has done in Christ (Rm 5:1-5, 1 Co 15:19f). It is the eager longing for eschatological salvation (Rm 8:18ff, Ph 1:20).

 

v.4 continues his thanksgiving, but adds another motive; their election by God. Paul insists that their adherence to Christ does not ultimately rest on any virtue on their part. Being part of God's church is due to divine "election".  This derives from Paul's teach­ing on justification by faith; no one can be a Christian through his own achievement but only because a gracious God enables us, through the death and resurrection of Christ.  Election is therefore the first act of the grace of God towards us. Problem: does the election of some to receive divine grace, not imply the rejection of others? It is doubtful that Paul ever taught the doctrine of positive damnation, though he comes close to it in Rm 9:13 (Esau) and 9:22 ("vessels of wrath"); and it is found elsewhere in the NT (1 Pt 2:8, Jude 4, Rev l3:8, 17:8). 

 

v.  5 egenethe ("the Good News was unto you"): the strange use of the impersonal verb is a way of stressing that it was not the preachers who really brought the Gospel, but God himself.

not in:.  Sometimes Paul likes to emphasize the positive by preceding it with the negative. Among the Thessalonians the Gospel has been present not just by words, but with the power of God's Holy Spirit and with full conviction.  This Gospel is not a philosophical opinion or a merely human message but divine activity. So contrasts his human words with the power of the Spirit and inner convic­tion.

en dynamei ("in power"):  this word, in the plural, sometimes refers to miracles, but here it is better taken together with en pneumati hagio, to mean something like "in the power of the Spirit", a phrase found in Lk 4:14 to describe the energetic beginnings of Jesus' own ministry.  Elsewhere, Paul often as­sociates "power" and "Spirit", as in 1 Co 2:4 ("demonstration of the Spirit and of power", 1 Co 15:43-44 ("raised in power... raised a spiritual body"), Rm 15:13 ("by the power of the Holy Spirit, you may abound in hope").

 

          This is the earliest textual example of Paul's attributing an inner, divine power to the Gospel message.  This is something he has learnt from personal experience, and in which he deeply believes.  It helps explain his amazing energy as an apostle, this feeling that his ministry was directly upheld by the Lord.  In the opening chapter of Romans he will write, "I am not ashamed of the Gospel;  it is the power of God for salvation, to every one who has faith" (Rm 1:16). In his Gospel work, Paul felt in touch with God's own power at work, the power of Israel's God directing history, which had also raised Jesus from the dead. Gospel preaching can call faith into existence; and no human power is able to produce faith: it is uniquely the work of God and of His Word.

 

v.6     Paradoxically, "affliction" is included among the grounds for thanksgiving.  He sees thlipsis (tribulation) as a normal condition for Christians, in an unbelieving world not yet fully redeemed.  Often he mentions the paradox of joy in the midst of suffering (Rm 5:3 has the chain-reaction of "we rejoice in our sufferings:. endurance:. character:. hope"; see also, 2 Co 7:4 "with all our affliction, I am overjoyed"; Ph 4:11 "I have learnt, in whatever state I am, to be content".    This is not just the human joy that may come from the sense of a duty carried to fruition, but a joy which originates in God and is mediated by his Spirit to those who suffer for his sake.

 

Imitation is one of Paul's favorite pastoral themes. The apostolic person teaches by example as well as by word, especially by courage and endurance.  Later he urges the Corinthians "Be imitators of me" (1 Co 4:16) "as I am of Christ" (11:1); and the Philippians "join in imitating me, and mark those who so live as you have an example in us" (Ph 3:17); and the Galatians "become as I am, for I also have become as you are" (Ga 4:12).  This was especially important as a motive for perseverance in those early days, to counter the temptation to fall away from the faith, under the stress of rejection by family or society for being a Christian.

 

vv.7-8 The idea of imitation continues, but now it is the Thessalonian converts themselves who provide the example (typos) to Christians in other places. Everywhere may well be an exaggeration, but their situation on the Via Egnatia would certainly help in spreading the news of their conversion. Possibly he is also visualizing what joy will be felt in the churches in Palestine and Syria, on hearing how the faith has spread to Macedonia.

 

v.9 He has no need to tell other churches about his mission to the Thessalonians and their great response of faith: these others, autoi, already spread the news of what has happened. "My friends", he seems to say, "your faith is an inspiring example!"

 

          He then uses what sounds like a credal formula to describe their conversion.  In contrast to their previous worship of useless idols, they have turned to the living and true God, the author of life.  Their new relationship to the one true God is described as service, doulein.  The term implies obedience in every area of life, for the kyrios has total domain over the doulos.  They now belong fully to God.

 

v. 10 Converted from idolatry, serving the true God, they wait eagerly for God's Son from heaven - the return of Jesus, to bring them full and final deliverance.  In their new faith, they expect to be saved from the approaching wrath of God.

 

          Obviously, it was Paul himself who planted among his converts that excited hope of Parousia, which he further encourages later in this letter (4:17; 5:6), but which he tries to calm down into a more sober outlook in 2 Thessalonians.

 

          How are we to understand Paul's talk of God's "wrath", orge? It is a difficult idea, not easily reconciled with the abundant love and mercy which the NT, following Jesus, attributes to the Father. Fitzmyer (JBC 53:18) describes it as "God's reaction to man's sin and evil ways :. an OT anthropomorphic image. (see Is 30:27-33).  It is neither a malicious hatred nor a jealous caprice, but the living God's steadfast reaction to Israel's breach of the covenant relationship (Ez 5:13, Hos 5:10, Is 9:8-12), or to the nations oppression of his people (Is 10:5ff, Jer 50:11-17, Ez 36:5-6). 

          Paul is quite clear that the personal God does not condone sin and will bring judgement. To oversimplify a bit, we could say that anger or wrath inevitably follow sin as effect follows cause. Certainly it serves to highlight the serious conse­quences of human actions, and God's hatred for sin. However its usefulness as a term of religious discourse for today is questionable, since it can too easily evoke a serious misconception about Christian morality.

 

C) Body of the Letter (1 Th 2:1 - 3:13): Kindly Reminiscence

          Contrary to what we normally find in Paul's letters, after the thanksgiving he does not pass into doctrinal considerations, but continues on the theme of his relationship with the Thes­salonian community.  He dwells, almost obsessively, on how well he has gotten on with them, and how blameless his conduct has been. The best explanation for this is surely that, along with good news, Timothy also reported some hints of criticism in that church, which could lead to disaffection from Paul, if he did not set the record straight.

 

          In the process of painting an edifying picture of the work done in Thessalonica by Silas, Timothy and himself, he provides more detailed information on this than in any other of his epistles.  The note of thanksgiving recurs in 2:13, because of the perfect reception accorded to the apostolic preaching as "Word of God, not the word of men".  This is an important doctrinal point for Paul, though only lightly touched upon here.  Likewise, he gives a hint of his central moral insight in the fact that he urged them to "lead a life worthy of God, who calls you into his own kingdom and glory" (2:12).

 

Insistence on daily work 

          What criticism was levelled at Paul, to provoke his insistence on "laboring day and night, that we might not burden any of you" (2:9)? Did some object to his prescription about ordinary daily work (4:11 "to work with your hands, as we charged you"), and accuse him of not following it himself? Though Paul did continue to do manual work (as a tent-maker, according to Ac 18:3), his working hours may well have been so curtailed by preaching activities as to make some supplementary income necessary. It is certain that he twice received a gift of money while at Thes­salonica (Ph 4:16) - and this could have prompted the suspicion on the part of some "enthusiast" Christians that Paul practiced the very lifestyle (prayer and ministry, without any admixture of humdrum manual work) which he expressly forbade for them (4:11; 2 Th 3:12). Their unwillingness to follow his advice on this matter was the main motive for 2 Thess.

 

Letter as substitute for a visit (3:10)      Evidently Paul's preferred form of contact with the community would be a personal visit (prayed for in 3:11). His letter is just a preliminary means of maintaining communication - and of assuring them of that spiritual contact which he continually  maintained through prayer on their behalf. 

 

Prayer for their holiness (3:12-13)    This fervent plea shows what he hoped for his young communities: increase of their mutual love (agape)  establishment of their holiness (hagiosyne), i:e. positive practice of good deeds, and abstinence from evil; blameless life. Both aspects are developed in the next section.

                  

 

D) Exhortations  (4:1-5:24)

 "Finally brethren, we beseech and exhort you in the Lord Jesus..." This persuasive  genre will be the usual quality of the second half of each Pauline letter.  He prefaces his exhortations with three vital moral principles:

 

i. In the Lord Jesus:  Christian moral appeal is not centered on Law, but on the people's loyalty to Christ.  He also implies that Christ is the source of his moral teaching, whether this came to Paul directly (by inspiration and reflection), or indirectly (by the mediation of those who had been with Jesus).

 

ii. more and more: typical of the Apostle, to see the task of pleasing God as an ongoing process, continuing to challenge our generosity until the very end of life. This reflects his personal experience, as he later professes in Ph 3:12 "Not that I have yet obtained this or am already perfect; but I press on to make it my own"

 

iii. the will of God, your sanctification: He sees morality not in terms of natural law, but as the will of God. This accords with the attitude of Jesus, reflected in the Gospels (Mt 6:10 etc:)  

 

Practical Moral Guidelines

 

          These are focussed on what, (expanding Flanagan's suggestion in Friend Paul 44), I would call the Six C's:   Chastity,  Charity and Common sense, Consolation and the Coming of Jesus, Community Ideal.

 

i. Chastity:

 

          This would distinguish them from the promiscuity of the pagan society from which they had converted.  Paul's expression of this in male-dominated categories reflects the attitude of his times. "Holiness and honor" describes the ideal of mutual respect and affection within marriage.

 

ii. Charity and Commonsense:

 

          They are distinguished by the warmth of their philadelphia (brotherly love) - a virtue "taught by God", with which the community is gifted. Reminiscent of the new age promised in Jer 31:33-34 ("I will write my law upon their hearts"). Still, in some of them an excessive religious enthusiasm has displaced the sense responsibility and good citizenship. Even in this period of excited expectation, Christians must work for their living, and not expect others to support them.

 

          The stern admonition in 2 Th 3:10-13 about working quietly and steadily, rather than living in idleness, shows how big a problem this was. It would also explain why Paul adopts the notion that signs will precede the Lord's Return; this would cool the ardent excitement, and allow the enthusiasm to settle into the humdrum duties of work and family life.

 

iii. Consolation and the Coming of the Lord

 

          Paul offers a motive of hope and consolation (4:13-18) about those Christians who have "fallen asleep" (= died). He considers it a most important point ("We would not have you ignorant about.." cf:Rm 1:13), that they will have equal share in the joyful encounter with Christ, in the Parousia. Resurrection is their hope; just as Paul expects himself and his readers to be still alive to enjoy their transit from earth to paradise. The imagery describing the Parousia (command, angel, trumpet of God, clouds) is that of the OT theophanies, and of apocalyptic literature; yet the faith-insight it embodies is vital to the Church:  Christ will come, to gather his people (cf. Mt 24-25).

 

          The date of the Parousia is, however, secret (5:1-11): this should counter the temptation to complacency or to slipping back into the more comfortable ethics of paganism. Paul urges alertness and high moral vigilance, playing on the contrast between light and darkness - a popular image in Judaism, related to "the day of the Lord" (Am 5:18; Is 5:20; Joel 4:14), and of great significance in the Qumran sect ("Sons of Light" versus "Sons of Darkness").

 

iv. Ideals for Community Living (5:12-22)

 

          As though conscious of running short of space on his scroll, Paul packs a wealth of exhortation into these eleven verses, which are directed initially (but not exclusively) to the church leaders, the Pro-istamenoi "who are over you in the Lord".  It is a wonderful and challenging vision of what a vibrant community could be, with its ministry focussed upon encouragement and up-building; joyful, prayerful, respectful; open to the gifts of the Spirit, but also able to discern the genuine from false claims to inspiration.

 

          Some commentators see this whole paragraph as addressed only to the recognized Church-leaders (who have the task of labouring, caring, admonishing), it is difficult to avoid the impression that Paul intends all members of the community to share in a sense of responsibility for each other's welfare. Certainly, verses 15-20 (calling for non-retaliation, rejoicing in spirit, prayer and thankfulness, openness to the Spirit's promptings) seem to apply equally to the "ordinary faithful" as to the Pro-istmenoi.  Surely Paul also wished to involve every adult Christian in the process of discerning good from evil (vv.21-22; cf Ph 4:8ff).

 

Final Greetings (5:23-28)

 These are in Paul's warm and hearty style, calling on the "God of peace" (Rm 15:33; 1 Co 14:33; 2 Co 13:11; Ph 4:9) to fill them with the blessing of holiness.  "Spirit, soul and body" - the total person, in Paul's vocabulary, for whom psyche is the body's animating principle, while pneuma is the divine spark especially given as Christ's gift to those who receive him in faith.

 

He will do it: after all the exhorting to high moral ideals, in the end Paul returns attention to the source of all good.

 

The holy kiss, sign of acceptance and affection within the Christian community, was probably given at liturgy; which was also the context for the public reading of Paul's letters.

 

The prevailing mood and spirit

The prevailing mood and spirit  of this first of Paul's letters is an enthusiastic, joyful expectation of salvation, at the coming of the Lord. In the brief intervening period, Paul expects his Christians to distinguish themselves by a life worthy of their high calling. The ideals are high, but are deemed possible with the guaranteed help of God, poured out on all who have living faith.